Tactical Advice

Does the Web Need a .data gTLD?

Debate continues over custom gTLDs as Stephen Wolfram ponders the utility of .data on the web.
Does the Web Need a .data gTLD?

The decision by ICANN to allow for custom generic top-level domains has caused ripples in the tech community and beyond. The FTC recently wrote a strongly worded letter condemning the decision, but still ICANN pressed forward with its plan.

Stephen Wolfram, a world-renowned British computer scientist, recently pondered the usefulness of a .data gTLD in a blog post. As inventor of the Wolfram Alpha, the answer-engine that Apple’s Siri taps into for its intelligent responses, he sees potential in a .data gTLD that would be aimed at automated systems, as opposed to humans or search engines. Wolfram writes:

There are product catalogs, store information, event calendars, regulatory filings, inventory data, historical reference material, contact information — lots of things that can be very usefully computed from. But even if these things are somewhere on an organization’s website, there’s no standard way to find them, let alone standard structured formats for them.

My concept for the .data domain is to use it to create the “data web” — in a sense a parallel construct to the ordinary web, but oriented toward structured data intended for computational use. The notion is that alongside a website like wolfram.com, there’d be wolfram.data.

If a human went to wolfram.data, there’d be a structured summary of what data the organization behind it wanted to expose. And if a computational system went there, it’d find just what it needs to ingest the data, and begin computing with it.

But Paul Miller of CloudAve takes an opposing view. He sees a .data gTLD as only adding to the confusion, and as he points out, many .gov, .edu and .com sites are using data subdomains to achieve essentially what Wolfram is arguing for. Miller writes:

Data without context is far less valuable than data with context. Much of that context may be inferred from the domain in which the data lives, with data delivered from a .gov or .edu (or .gov.uk or .ac.uk) site perhaps interpreted differently to data hosted on .com, .biz, or .xxx.

Southampton University, the Open University, and the US Federal Government are able to gather data up and make it available for download via their existing data sites if they choose. This offers human visitors to their sites a degree of convenience, whilst retaining the power and brand attributes of their existing domain.

Gov.data, gov.uk.data, open.ac.uk.data, southampton.ac.uk.data, though? All are messy, in ways that Wolfram’s own wolfram.data would admittedly not be, and all are simply additional registrations that the institutions would have to pay for in order to stop someone else from grabbing the domain.

The idea of standardizing an area for data on the web is a powerful concept. A retailer could easily set up a .data version of its site and allow application developers to tap into its inventory and catalogues, further fueling innovations in the online-shopping experience.

What do you think? Is the effort best left at the subdomain level, or does big data warrant its own gTLD?

Sign up for our e-newsletter

About the Author

Ricky Ribeiro

Online Content Manager

Ricky publishes and manages the content on BizTech magazine's web site. He's a writer, technology enthusiast, social media lover and all-around digital guy. You can learn more by following him on Google+ or Twitter:

Security

Securing the Internet of Thi... |
As excitement around the connected-device future grows, technology vendors seek ways to...
Tools to Maintain Mobile Sec... |
Far-flung devices pose serious challenges, but a variety of technologies can help protect...
Edward Snowden Personifies t... |
The NSA leak shows critical areas where organizations can better protect their data.

Storage

The New Backup Utility Proce... |
Just getting used to the Windows 8 workflow? Prepare for a change.
How to Perform Traditional W... |
With previous versions going unused, Microsoft radically reimagined the backup utility in...
5 Easy Ways to Build a Bette... |
While large enterprises have the resources of an entire IT department behind them, these...

Infrastructure Optimization

Ensure Uptime Is in Your Dat... |
Power and cooling solutions support disaster recovery and create cost savings and...
The Value of Converged Infra... |
Improvements in security, management and efficiency are just a few of the benefits CI can...
Curse Builds a Private Cloud... |
One of the top resources in online gaming builds out a robust infrastructure that can...

Networking

Securing the Internet of Thi... |
As excitement around the connected-device future grows, technology vendors seek ways to...
How to Maximize WAN Bandwidt... |
Understand six common problems that plague wide area networks — and how to address them.
Linksys Makes a Comeback in... |
The networking vendor introduced several new Smart Switch products at Interop this week.

Mobile & Wireless

Now that Office for iPad Is... |
After waiting awhile for Microsoft’s productivity suite to arrive, professionals who use...
Visualization Can Help Busin... |
Companies need to put their data in formats that make it consumable anytime, anywhere.
Linksys Makes a Comeback in... |
The networking vendor introduced several new Smart Switch products at Interop this week.

Hardware & Software

Visualization Can Help Busin... |
Companies need to put their data in formats that make it consumable anytime, anywhere.
The Tools That Power Busines... |
Ever-evolving analytic software can greatly improve financial institutions’ decision-...
XP-iration Date: Today Is th... |
It’s officially lights out for Windows XP as an operating system. Here’s how the world is...